News:

BEFORE POSTING read our Guidelines.

Main Menu

Parry Piano Trios 1 & 3

Started by Alan Howe, Monday 29 October 2018, 23:00

Previous topic - Next topic

Alan Howe

I'm not sure I agree that the Meridian performances are 'excellent'. They're good, of course, but the string playing seems fuller and more secure on the new release. I'd say the Hyperion is definitely worth a punt.

semloh

Another part of that post you quoted said
"Why bandy about a word like masterpiece, it does not help in evaluating them."


Well, I think we'll have to agree to disagree over that one, Santo.

Santo Neuenwelt

Why do you say we disagree, do you think they are is a masterworks? I thought you wrote you did not think so. I wrote why even talk about that. I did not call them masterpieces, I said they are very good, nothing more. I would think we are in agreement, unless, of course, I misunderstood what you wrote and you do not think they are very good...if that is the case, then we do disagree.