Unsung Composers

The Web Site => Suggestions & Problems => Topic started by: kyjo on Friday 10 August 2012, 03:08

Title: Superhero Member Status?
Post by: kyjo on Friday 10 August 2012, 03:08
Since some members here (Eric, Alan, Colin, Mark,etc.) are getting up there in posts, I think we should have another status be reached at 5,000 posts, namely the Superhero Status :D! No doubt Eric would be getting there in no time! The only reason this wouldn't work is if members think it's a stupid idea ;D! So, what do you think of my suggestion ::)?
Title: Re: Superhero Member Status?
Post by: Mark Thomas on Friday 10 August 2012, 08:42
I can't avoid sounding plonking here, so I'll take a deep breath and plonk away!

Kyjo, the number of posts which someone makes is quite irrelevant to anything, except possibly the amount of time they've been a member. Some people have more time than others. I can think of several members who have posted comparatively few times but whose contribution I always value and whose posts provoke a lot of thought. It isn't a  race. The software comes with various categories of members built in, I don't particularly like them and could switch them off, I suppose, but I just haven't bothered because it isn't important to me. As always, whilst I'm not looking for non-stop profundity (and certainly don't provide that myself) it's the quality of the posts that matters, never the number.

Plonk over.
Title: Re: Superhero Member Status?
Post by: Alan Howe on Friday 10 August 2012, 09:54
It's a bad idea, kyjo. Do take the hint. Please...
Title: Re: Superhero Member Status?
Post by: JimL on Friday 10 August 2012, 14:12
You're young, aren't you kyjo?
Title: Re: Superhero Member Status?
Post by: Ser Amantio di Nicolao on Friday 10 August 2012, 15:03
I don't know - it could be fun.  If - and only if - each superhero is given a composer avatar.  Then we could have composer cage matches and take bets on the outcome.

I'm already salivating at the thought of a fight to the death between George W. Chadwick and Horatio Parker.  (Referee: Charles Ives, which means that illegal and unexpected maneuvers are applauded and encouraged.)  The winner takes on Anthony Philip Heinrich for winner of the Greatest Unsung American Hero award.

(In a related note, I'm not entirely serious, as you might imagine...)
Title: Re: Superhero Member Status?
Post by: Arbuckle on Friday 10 August 2012, 16:11
One might argue that the names you mentioned are already "superheroes" because of the high quality and solidity of the information they provide in their posts, many or few. Arbuckle
Title: Re: Superhero Member Status?
Post by: kyjo on Friday 10 August 2012, 16:59
OK, so it's a stupid idea ;D! Just thought I'd throw it out there ::)!
Title: Re: Superhero Member Status?
Post by: JimL on Saturday 11 August 2012, 01:22
Just about every superhero I know of preferred to be known by his alter ego when he/she wasn't working.  ;)
Title: Re: Superhero Member Status?
Post by: kyjo on Saturday 11 August 2012, 17:11
Well, I didn't mean to imply a superhero in that sense, Jim ;D!
Title: Re: Superhero Member Status?
Post by: Alan Howe on Saturday 11 August 2012, 17:51
I think this daft thread has run its course...
Title: Re: Superhero Member Status?
Post by: kyjo on Monday 13 August 2012, 19:13
Agreed, Alan. I never realize how stupid my ideas are until after I post them ;D!
Title: Re: Superhero Member Status?
Post by: Mark Thomas on Monday 13 August 2012, 19:49
OK, let's draw a veil over this episode now, please.