Unsung Composers

The Music => Recordings & Broadcasts => Topic started by: Justin on Wednesday 09 September 2020, 17:10

Title: Horst Platen - Violin Concerto
Post by: Justin on Wednesday 09 September 2020, 17:10
Just uploaded a recording of Horst Platen's lovely violin concerto conducted by Platen himself.

Do any of the members have info on when this was composed? It is certainly in the romantic style, but I am having trouble pinpointing any particular decade.
Title: Re: Horst Platen - Violin Concerto
Post by: Alan Howe on Wednesday 09 September 2020, 17:32
There's also this performance on YouTube:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2YG8cclf_fU (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2YG8cclf_fU)

Details:

Violin Concerto in G Major
I. Leicht bewegt
II. Langsam 
III. Rhythmisch bewegt
Walter Forchert, violin
Bamberg Symphony Orchestra
Jiri Starek, conductor

Title: Re: Horst Platen - Violin Concerto
Post by: Wheesht on Wednesday 09 September 2020, 19:01
Interesting that both recordings should have the same error in the movement titles: Rythmisch instead of the correct Rhythmisch – and what on earth is bericht with a lower case 'b' supposed to mean?
Title: Re: Horst Platen - Violin Concerto
Post by: Holger on Wednesday 09 September 2020, 21:07
Yes indeed, the titles of the first and third movements do not make sense. It seems reasonable that it should be "bewegt" instead of "bericht" (there is a "Bericht" in German but that's a noun and means "report"). To clarify the issue, I had a look at Tobias Bröker's catalogue of 20th century violin concertos, and indeed, this is true. In fact, here the titles are given as

I. Leicht bewegt
II. Sehr langsam
III. Rhythmisch bewegt.
Title: Re: Horst Platen - Violin Concerto
Post by: Mark Thomas on Wednesday 09 September 2020, 22:02
Thanks, that helps a lot.
Title: Re: Horst Platen - Violin Concerto
Post by: Alan Howe on Wednesday 09 September 2020, 22:56
Indeed. Most remiss of me to copy and fail to check. I was in rather a hurry. I have corrected my original post.

Toskey doesn't list the work, I note.
Title: Re: Horst Platen - Violin Concerto
Post by: Justin on Friday 27 September 2024, 04:20
Found a photograph of Platen on the second page of a flyer for a theater in Fürth:

https://www.fuerthwiki.de/wiki/images/f/f4/Theaterflyer_F%C3%BCrth_1941.pdf (https://www.fuerthwiki.de/wiki/images/f/f4/Theaterflyer_F%C3%BCrth_1941.pdf)
Title: Re: Horst Platen - Violin Concerto
Post by: Wheesht on Friday 27 September 2024, 06:19
Interesting. He looks quite different in the biographical entry on the same Fürth Wiki (https://www.fuerthwiki.de/wiki/index.php/Horst_Platen).
Title: Re: Horst Platen - Violin Concerto
Post by: Alan Howe on Friday 27 September 2024, 08:28
Dates: 1884-1964. No details given about his mellifluous Violin Concerto, unfortunately.
Title: Re: Horst Platen - Violin Concerto
Post by: Maury on Friday 27 September 2024, 17:41
Platen has a rather interesting bio with his early association with radio broadcasts. He definitely seems to lean toward the lighter side given that he was composing incidental music for radio plays and composed operettas. Wiki does list two operas composed by my cutoff of 1925 for authentic neo Romanticism. The Violin Concerto seems rather gentle and not particularly heavy. I found the outer two movements better than what seems to me a too hesitant slower middle  movement. I would guess it was done after WW1. I would like to hear his stage works.
Title: Re: Horst Platen - Violin Concerto
Post by: eschiss1 on Sunday 29 September 2024, 04:30
As to the violin concerto, I can't seem to locate any notice of a performance before the recording, or other information that might give some even rough estimate for its composition date. I'm gathering it wasn't published, apparently.
Title: Re: Horst Platen - Violin Concerto
Post by: Maury on Sunday 29 September 2024, 10:03
Regarding the Platen VC I wouldn't be surprised if it was unperformed. Violinists particularly of that era wanted something more stirring and dynamic. In addition as a (school) violinist myself, I would have required him to rewrite the middle movement to give it more depth and feeling to counterbalance the appealing but lighter outer movements. I find what little music I've heard of Platen to be interesting but perhaps he wasn't getting much critical feedback in the somewhat out of the mainstream positions he was in before 1946.