Unsung Composers

The Music => Composers & Music => Topic started by: eschiss1 on Saturday 06 March 2021, 13:28

Title: Farrenc’s other piano concertante
Post by: eschiss1 on Saturday 06 March 2021, 13:28
Does anyone know of a recording of this set (https://imslp.org/wiki/Variations_pour_piano_et_orchestre_(Farrenc,_Louise)) of piano and orchestra variations by Louise Farrenc in F (mirrored from BNF), apparently not engraved, or some other info about it? Looks interesting.
Other as in not the Gallenberg set whose orchestral form was recently recorded.
Title: Re: Farrenc’s other piano concertante
Post by: Double-A on Saturday 06 March 2021, 22:34
Do you know: Is this Farrenc's usual handwriting? It looks awfully anal to me.
Title: Re: Farrenc’s other piano concertante
Post by: Alan Howe on Saturday 06 March 2021, 22:54
QuoteIt looks awfully anal to me

Please explain!
Title: Re: Farrenc’s other piano concertante
Post by: Double-A on Sunday 07 March 2021, 01:10
The writing looks as if an extremely, shockingly perfectionist person wrote it.  There were other composers who wrote beautiful manuscripts.  Bach would probably be the best example.  But Bach's or Mozart's and Röntgen's handwriting has a personal appearance, is obviously the work of an adult.  This work looks like written by an extremely conscientious school age child.  Look at the alto clef for example:  How long do you think it takes to write it like this (on every page!)?

To me it does just not fit the person I imagine composed Farrenc's music.
Title: Re: Farrenc’s other piano concertante
Post by: Gareth Vaughan on Sunday 07 March 2021, 01:19
It might be a copyist's hand. I've seen plenty of scores similarly transcribed. I don't think it is childlike. It is far too fluent for that. 19th century copyists were very skilled in producing neat, uniform scores.
Title: Re: Farrenc’s other piano concertante
Post by: eschiss1 on Sunday 07 March 2021, 02:26
Oh. I just found the catalog listing. Sorry, I wasted everyone's time. It's Moscheles' op.32 (Grandes variations sur un thème militaire), as possibly (piano/)orchestrated by Farrenc; IMSLP has it mislisted. Just moved the page (and put the file under Moscheles' op.32 variations.)