Unsung Composers

The Music => Recordings & Broadcasts => Topic started by: Justin on Monday 05 September 2022, 18:32

Title: Patric Standford - Cello Concerto (1976)
Post by: Justin on Monday 05 September 2022, 18:32
I would like to share from YouTube a Cello Concerto by "Rod McKuen," actually ghostwritten by Patric Standford. It was composed in 1976 but it follows the British Neo-Romantic style.

https://youtu.be/CnVYgU-jauo (https://youtu.be/CnVYgU-jauo)

Cello – Keith Harvey
Conductor – Patric Standford
Orchestra – National Philharmonic Orchestra
Title: Re: Patric Standford - Cello Concerto (1976)
Post by: Gareth Vaughan on Monday 05 September 2022, 21:02
Why would McKuen want to get Standford to write a cello concerto to appear under his (McKuen's) name? It sounds like something Ketelbey might have written - at least, the opening does. But I must listen to the whole thing, of course, before passing judgement; not that saying it sounds like Ketelbey is meant to imply adverse criticism - it isn't.
Title: Re: Patric Standford - Cello Concerto (1976)
Post by: Alan Howe on Monday 05 September 2022, 22:32
Perhaps it was because Standford wasn't writing in his own style? After all, it is extremely sentimental.

I'm not sure what the 'British Neo-Romantic style' might be. As Gareth suggests, this could be by Ketelby...
Title: Re: Patric Standford - Cello Concerto (1976)
Post by: Justin on Monday 05 September 2022, 22:43
From what I have read, McKuen often got commissions for various functions and fell behind in his work. It was common for him to take on too many projects at once and abandon them.

He wrote sketches of the single melody line of the cello, and Standford built the concerto around that in 10 days. The liner notes of the album suggest however that McKuen wrote it all by himself in 2 weeks and that it was recorded at St Giles-without-Cripplegate. Standford's Estate website says it was done in a recording studio.
Title: Re: Patric Standford - Cello Concerto (1976)
Post by: eschiss1 on Wednesday 07 September 2022, 19:26
I see that both of them are dead now so if there was ever any chance of simply asking them, there hasn't been for 7-odd years...
Title: Re: Patric Standford - Cello Concerto (1976)
Post by: semloh on Sunday 11 September 2022, 01:18
Now this is 'treacly' enough to challenge Tate & Lyle!  ;D
As you said, Alan, not at all in Patric Standford's personal style.
Title: Re: Patric Standford - Cello Concerto (1976)
Post by: Justin on Sunday 11 September 2022, 03:19
It was premiered at the Royal Albert Hall on September 17, 1976 and conducted by Standford. I can't find any reviews of that performance but I wonder how it was received.
Title: Re: Patric Standford - Cello Concerto (1976)
Post by: Justin on Monday 21 August 2023, 09:46
Gareth, I'm curiously what your thoughts are on the complete work?
Title: Re: Patric Standford - Cello Concerto (1976)
Post by: Gareth Vaughan on Monday 21 August 2023, 16:01
Well, I found it disappointing, I'm sorry to say. There are some lovely tunes, but none of these is properly developed and most of them are rather sugary. The composition is very episodic and lacks structure. As a result, I am afraid I quickly got bored. The principal redeeming feature is Standford's orchestration which is hugely accomplished and colourful.
Title: Re: Patric Standford - Cello Concerto (1976)
Post by: Justin on Wednesday 23 August 2023, 01:37
I'll generally agree with you that there seems to be a "novel" effect to the cello which is McKuen's doing, and I'm sure some of McKuen's fans thought it was wonderful just by the general sound.

It's a piece you can play pleasantly in the background, and you are correct in terms of Standford's wonderful strings which paint a vast landscape to boost the work a bit.