News:

BEFORE POSTING read our Guidelines.

Main Menu
Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - Alan Howe

#9616
The Granados isn't really a reconstruction at all, but an invention. From Hyperion's website:

Like Albéniz, Enrique Granados (1867–1916) was a brilliant pianist (he studied with Charles de Bériot in Paris) and a composition pupil of Felipe Pedrell. Both are best remembered as composers of overtly Spanish piano cycles (Albéniz's Iberia and Granados's Goyescas), but both also wrote extensively in other forms, including opera, a form in which Pedrell was also active. The Centre de Documentació Musical de Catalunya in Barcelona has two tantalizing fragments of a piano concerto by Granados which Melani Mestre has taken as the point of departure for a finished work. The first of the Barcelona manuscripts is a two-piano sketch in Granados's hand, with a dedication 'à mon cher maître Camille Saint-Saëns', and the subtitle 'Patético'. Though this manuscript has no date, Melani Mestre has suggested that it was written in 1910, around the time Granados was at work on Goyescas.

The sketch opens with a long, brooding piano solo, and the tempo changes to Allegro grave non molto lento when the orchestra makes its first entry. Altogether there are some 250 bars of music in this sketch, which breaks off in the middle of a bar. A second autograph manuscript is much neater, but the opening solo, marked Lento grave e quasi recitativo, is considerably shorter (just eighteen bars—less than a quarter of the length of this solo in the sketch), before the initial fully scored orchestral entry. This manuscript has several blank pages between orchestral entries where Granados may have intended to add the solo part, and it ends with nine pages of full orchestral score before stopping abruptly.

Musicologists will never agree about the viability of completing a work that exists only in a fragmentary state, and for which there is no surviving continuity draft to indicate what Granados's intentions might have been for the entire movement. Putting those questions to one side, what Mestre's completion demonstrates is that the surviving sources provide ample material for a single movement of considerable interest. The music is unusually dark and sombre, centred on C minor (the key of Beethoven's 'Pathétique' Sonata, presumably no accident given the subtitle 'Patético' on the sketch), and Granados can be heard here at his most gravely expressive and harmonically resourceful. It is unclear whether he set out to write a three-movement concerto (there is some evidence that he did), or whether he thought that this substantial single movement could stand on its own. Mestre believes that Granados had a three-movement work in mind, and to create that (since there is only material for the first movement in the Barcelona manuscripts) he has taken two solo piano works, orchestrating and adapting them for piano and orchestra. The second movement is based on two pieces: Oriental, No 2 of the twelve Danzas españolas, and Capricho español. The finale is an arrangement of the Allegro di concierto.

(emphasis added)
#9618
We could be, Tom. But the Granados realisation is an example of a peculiarly modern phenomenon. It's almost a type of personal wish-fulfilment.
#9619
Well, Herz is frivolous. That's the whole point. Anyway, if returning to the 'bejewelled territory of this Austro-Parisian sensation' is damning with faint praise, I'm a banana...
#9620
I like Ryelandt's 3rd Symphony, but frankly I want more. Just as the music gets going it seems to lose its way. It's all very attractive, sometimes more than that, but the level of inspiration isn't consistent.
#9621
Recordings & Broadcasts / More Herz from Hyperion
Saturday 09 May 2015, 21:42
From Hyperion's website:

Fans of more frivolous piano fare will welcome our 66th Romantic Piano Concerto series release. Howard Shelley and the Tasmanian Symphony Orchestra have recorded Henri Herz Piano Concerto No 2 & other works, their third and final visit to the bejewelled territory of this Austro-Parisian sensation.
http://www.hyperion-records.co.uk/ym.asp?ym=2015_08
#9622
Composers & Music / Re: Not what it says on the tin
Saturday 09 May 2015, 21:39
Aren't we talking here about modern-day realisations, though?
#9623
Composers & Music / Re: Not what it says on the tin
Saturday 09 May 2015, 18:12
The 'completion/realisation' industry is in full swing these days. Of course, on occasions the result is a revelation (who'd be without Elgar/Payne Symphony 3?), but more often than not the product is some sort of hybrid using original material by the composer involved which is then imaginatively re-composed by someone else. I have no particular objections myself to this industry provided that it is made clear what one is buying into. So the real issue for me is what these hybrid works should be called. In the case of the Granados, for example, I'd've thought the piece should be called Concerto for Piano and Orchestra 'Patético' by Melani Mestre after music by Enrique Granados. In other words the name of the person responsible for the completion/realisation should really be up front and central.
#9624
Oh, that's a relief. Mind you, it took me a while to find my copy and I'm only 61... ;)
#9625
...which is precisely what the O'Brien Symphony won't do! Mark is 100% right.
#9626
But "nothing there to frighten the horses" is actually an expression of relief that the music is likely to be perfectly acceptable on this forum.
#9627
Wonder where I got it from? Are you sure you didn't have it already?
#9628
He does and doesn't fit. Frankly, I find him a more or less total bore, notwithstanding some passing passages of extraordinary beauty.
#9629
I appear to have this in my collection:

Robert Radecke (1830-1911):Piano Trio No.1 in A flat major, Op.30 (1865)
1.   (8:02)
2.   (3:35) 
3.   (8:10)
4.   (8:41) 
Basler Trio

Is this the same recording?
#9630
Composers & Music / Re: Alfano Risurrezione
Friday 08 May 2015, 18:19
I haven't listened to Siberia for ages. Must dig it out...