Messages

Re. Pick-Mangiagalli, the 3 miniatures for piano & orchestra and Sortilegi are in Fleisher (scores and parts - https://catalog.freelibrary.org/Record/869212 and https://catalog.freelibrary.org/Record/869208), while the piano concerto is published by Schott who have performance material available for hire - https://www.schott-music.com/en/concerto-no356324.html.

I have the Classics for Pleasure CD and play it often.

This slim PDF may be of interest: https://www.snc.edu/northwind/documents/By_work/Phantastes/Gustav_Holst_and_George_MacDonald_-_R.B._Shaberman.pdf

Also this superficial and rather "undergraduate" posting: https://doublebassing.wordpress.com/2015/06/30/think-youre-a-failure-we-call-that-pulling-a-holst/

Colin Matthews, writing in The Musical Times, Vol. 125, No. 1695 (May, 1984), pp. 269+271-272 'Some Unknown Holst', makes a passing and dismissive reference to the suite: "In spite of the achievement of Savitri, Holst was still capable of misjudgements, notably the disastrous orchestral suite Phantastes (1911)..." but says no more about it.  The article can be read on JSTOR.

But somehow I doubt they will be!

Interesting. Seems to be lacking the piano part.

A deep search of InternetCulturale-Italia might turn up more orchestral and concertante works by the lost generation of 19th-century Italian composers, though.

Well, apart from the Pick-Mangiagalli pieces already mentioned above, the following come to mind:
Gino Tagliapietra: Concerto and Concertino for piano & orchestra (performance material for both apparently in Biblioteca nazionale Marciana in Venice)
Michele Eulambio: Concerto for piano & orchestra (the score of which Wheesht has kindly photocopied)
Attilio Brugnoli: Concerto for piano & orchestra (full score & 2piano score in Biblioteca nazionale centrale, Florence)
Ettore Pozzoli: Allegro di Concerto (I don't know where the score is or if it even exists still - he died in 1957)
and the piano concertos by Adolfo and Disma Fumagalli, of course.

Ah, yes. Thank you. This sort of thing sometimes happens with CPO booklets.

So it is, Eric. Your query is very pertinent. And I'm confused too. Which recording of the Buttner did you mean, Ilja?

Do you know, by the way, what else will be on the Lyrita disk?
I have not yet had a reply from Simon, which is unusual. He normally responds at once, but he is a very busy bee!

Brilliant news, promusician. I am delighted Simon is the pianist for the recording.

In August 2022 I wrote thus to pianist Simon Callaghan:
"I have just learned that, shortly before the pandemic, the autograph score of Sterndale Bennett's 6th piano concerto (in A minor) was deposited at the Bodleian Library and can now be accessed as MS. Odling Sterndale Bennett 43 and MS. Odling Sterndale Bennett 44. This concerto has long been known about but was inaccessible because the lady who owned it (the composer's great grand-daughter, I think) would not allow anyone to see it. I was given to understand she was prepared to sell it, but only at a very high price (though I do not know for certain the truth of this assertion). Anyway, it has now found its way to the Bodleian (apparently partly in lieu of estate death duties), so one can now examine it. Also deposited, though from a different family source, is the ms. of the concerto for 2 pianos and orchestra which Sterndale Bennett wrote in 1835 jointly with George MacFarren. This is MS. Sterndale Bennett 25 and is described thus: 'Autograph full score (damaged in places), signed by William Sterndale Bennett only, not dated.' One wonders about the extent of the damage. Nevertheless, it is of some considerable interest that these two works are now accessible to musicians. As you know, Sterndale Bennett's Piano Concertos 1-5 were recorded by Malcolm Binns for Lyrita many years ago, while Howard Shelley has more recently recorded 1-4 plus the Caprice and Adagio (the only other 2 extant works for piano & orchestra by Bennett) for Hyperion in the Romantic Piano Concerto Series. Perhaps Hyperion might be interested in recording PCs 5 & 6, together with the 2-piano concerto (provided it is in playable condition)."
The link to the entry for the MS in the Bodleian Catalogue is: https://archives.bodleian.ox.ac.uk/repositories/2/archival_objects/212272

Simon replied: "Gosh, how wonderful!  I'll try to get this asap, but it may be that someone has got there first... let's see!"

As members of this forum know, it was shortly after this exchange that I was diagnosed with my stomach cancer and started chemotherapy, ultimately undergoing a total gastrectomy in October 2023, from which it has taken me until now to recover properly. So I did not follow this up with Simon, but will now do so.

That's quite right, Eric. This is apparently the so called Piano Concerto No. 6, the MS of which was, until fairly recently, in private hands and unavailable to those who might have wished to study it.

I wonder if he has been sent a review copy.

Wow! I'm impressed. Very enterprising.

Oh yes, that is all very true. Doesn't mean to say one has to like it - but that's the way of the world, I suppose. (Though I must say I am surprised by the resurgence in vinyl - for me that's quite an odd development.)